Perseverance!

by

Gus doesn’t give up–he obviously has a highly developed sense of perseverance! Helping our students to persevere in the face of obstacles and frustration is a worthy academic and personal goal. One approach to increasing student capacity for perseverance is to incorporate small group problem-solving challenges in the curriculum.  Advisory is certainly an appropriate time, however this type of activity works well in academic classes as well.

Here’s a suggestion–don’t make the group challenges competitive and a one time event.  Instead, keep the small groups together over time and make the goal to improve their personal team “best” each time they attempt the challenge.  The “best” might be time or height or complexity. By competing against themselves, the students are less apt to give up and say, “We don’t have a chance against them!”

Also, by changing the conditions of the challenge, the team will  develop flexible thinking as well as perseverance.  Changes can be simple–no talking, have to use only one hand, some members of the group blindfolded, or use different materials, etc.

So… what might this strategy look like over time?  Watch the following video on the marshmallow challenge to see the basic structure:

Here’s an example of ways to change the challenge to keep the students’ interest and to help them persevere at problem solving:

  • Trial # 1: Basic challenge as described in the video
  • Trial # 2: No change, ask students to use what they learned the first time to make a taller structure than they did the first time
  • Trial # 3: Change the materials–instead of string and tape, give them 15 mini-marshmallows with the goal to build a taller tower
  • Trial # 4: Add a rule that they can’t talk while challenging them to build even a better tower

It’s important that after each trial to  have students  reflect in their small groups on their process for meeting the challenge:

  • What did the group do that enabled you to be successful?
  • What behaviors were not helpful?
  • What do you want to remember to do next time?
  • What behaviors or action that you used in this challenge might transfer to your classwork when you feel frustrated and don’t know what to do next?

Here are some sources of other physical problem-solving challenges that could be used:

Helping students develop perseverance is a lifetime skill that will serve them well.  We need to provide non-threatening opportunities for students to practice this habit of mind.

It’s not that I’m so smart, it’s just that I stay with problems longer. 

Albert Einstein

Advertisements

Tags: , ,

2 Responses to “Perseverance!”

  1. Ernie Easter Says:

    Maybe it is time to dust off some of the “Odyssey of the Mind”, Camp Kieve, Advisory curriculum, or other problem based / experiential learning challenges.

    The teacher’s challenge becomes finding the time within a day. Many teachers are stressed already with having to meet cookie cutter curriculum designed to keep them off the NCLB naughty list without being allowed via this curriculum to provide “experiences” for their students.

  2. Jill Spencer Says:

    Thanks for stopping by Ernie! The time issue is huge and many teachers face criticism if they are not working directly on the “designated” curriculum. I think my next post is going to be evidence for teachers to use when facing a negative reaction to learning activities such as these.

    Here’s one to start…
    Robert Marsano. “Using Games to Enhance Student Achievement” Educational Leadership Feb. 2010 (Vol. 67 # 5) pp.71-71.
    http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/feb10/vol67/num05/Using-Games-to-Enhance-Student-Achievement.aspx

    In the 60 studies Marzano has been involved in that include academic games as part of the instructional plan, there was up to and sometimes more than 20 percentile point gain in student achievement.

    What needs to be in place:
    • Use inconsequential competition
    • Target essential academic content
    • Debrief the game: What was the most difficult? What did you find to be easy? What questions do you still have?
    • Have students revise their notes: provide time for students to review their notes and make additions and deletions as necessary

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: